Online video creators, advertisers and producers have an unhealthy fascination with viral videos, and that obsession is dragging down the entire industry. Why? Because viral videos are, at their core, no better than a fluffernutter white-bread sandwich, delivering little or no value to anyone.
Online video hasn’t been a hotbed of success so far, and while I used to blame discovery, being relegated to the podcast ghetto and the immaturity of some of our biggest practitioners, those are just symptoms. It’s the incessant focus on viral success, I now believe, that’s really keeping us down.
Let’s start with producers and show creators. Media is all about building habits. Successful producers bind an audience to their creation, building an insatiable hunger for the next installment, next episode, next post. But when you focus on viral success, you throw that focus on repeatability out the window. By its nature, viral videos are designed to surprise, titillate and entertain. They are, by nature, unique; the 27th keyboard cat or the 12th dancing baby is just plain boring. But once video producers taste the heady success of a viral hit, they keep trying to re-create lightning in a bottle. But let’s face it — we all know "David Goes to the Proctologist" isn’t going to be nearly as successful as his trip to the dentist.
Viral videos are also terrible for video sites too. Sure, everyone loves to trumpet a single video with millions of views. But because viral videos are by their nature unpredictable, they can burn through an allocation of premium inventory rather rapidly. At most sites, there are only so many high-CPM advertisements ready to run at any given time. When they’re done, bottom-dwelling ad networks lurch into the void, spewing their cheapo ads for teeth whitening, belly flattening and nicotine-busting dreck. Ten predictable episodic shows that deliver a consistent 100,000 views an episode is far easier to plan for and monetize than a channel that has a one-in-100 chance of catching fire — and a 99-in-100 chance of bombing.
Viral videos may be bad for creators and publishers, but they are actually worse for advertisers. Your typical viral video gets passed around, yes, and drives a lot of views. And yes, those can translate into impressions for an advertiser. But as we’ve seen at Revision3, advertising associated with viral videos has only a small fraction of the impact of an ad that runs inside, or alongside, an episodic video program. We’ve seen tremendous results from putting brands next to our long-running episodic programs — those with real communities, high comment-to-view ratios and predictable views. We’ve seen terrible results by associating the same brands and services with the few viral-focused shows we’ve tried out over the last five years. And if you try creating those viral-focused videos yourself, you are in for a real surprise. It is overwhelmingly likely that you’ll end up with closer to a thousand views than a million.
There’s another thing to be wary of: fake views that make your viral campaign look like a success, when it’s actually a complete failure. There are many ways to juice views, exacerbated by the fact that YouTube and most other video sites tally up a view even if only a second of video plays. Your unscrupulous viral-video partner may be embedding an autoplay of your video below the fold on a variety of unrelated sites, and counting those views as success — when instead they are the worst sort of failure. Why failure? Because when your viewer realizes she’s been duped into viewing something unasked for, an angry STOP, and bad brand association, quickly follows.
But brands keep trying. And every time a new, apparently viral success emerges, even more dollars are wasted chasing chimerical views. Witness the Old Spice Guy phenomenon. Marketers worldwide are even now trying to replicate that success, without realizing viral was furthest from their minds. It started with a Super Bowl ad — hardly the norm for a viral-focused campaign, which hopes to get something for nothing. Each subsequent piece was part of a well thought out development of an engaging character, with the entire story arc and timing scripted in advance. They created a compelling, episodic video show, and spent millions up front to promote it.
Some of the best and most talented video producers focus their enormous talents on creating viral hits, instead of building repeatable episodic series that are built around an authentic host or an extended narrative. Yet in the end, those are the video properties that keep viewers coming back, provide predictable views that publishers covet and repeatable results that drive sales and profits.
There’s one area, though, where viral can be worthwhile: when you use one to build a sustainable audience for a well planned out video series. Dan Brown (aka Pogobat) did just that on YouTube. His videos went quickly viral when they were released three years ago, and have delivered nearly 27 million views so far. But instead of trying to replicate his viral success with an endless stream of Rubik-focused videos, he used that one to build a community around his daily thoughts, updates and experiences. He used viral to drive authenticity, and built up a community of nearly 300,000 friends — and recently he’s used that audience to drive branded success as well.
So what’s an advertiser to do? Stop chasing viral, and start looking closely at online video that delivers repeatable, measurable and sustainable views. When putting dollars behind video projects, make sure you understand exactly how the audience-development component works. You don’t want to pay for views that never actually get watched. And remember, just like with the Tortoise and the Hare, steady and consistent wins out over jackrabbit view spikes every time.
(Jim Louderback is CEO of video network Revision3, and would be happy to help you break the viral video habit – and this post was originally posted on AdAge – Thanks Guys!)
5 Thoughts on “Screw Viral Video – It’s Bad For Us All!”
You hit a nerve with me because I was just working on the final edits of my book Content Rules and we talk a bit about how brands need to stop wanting to “go viral” because it is not something you can force and even if you DO have it happen are you ready to jump on the “success” and make something of it.
Focus on creating good content that gets you on people’s radar an then do everything to keep them interested and coming back.
Someday the world will wake up to this.
PS – You now have me craving a fluffrrnutter in the biggest way. Only a fellow New England guy would use that image.Well done!
I used to be very pleased to find this internet-site.I wished to thanks for your time for this glorious read!! I undoubtedly enjoying every little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post.
Aw, this was a very nice post. In thought I would like to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and under no circumstances seem to get something done.
Hey! I simply would like to give an enormous thumbs up for the great data you have here on this post. I will be coming again to your blog for more soon.
I went over this web site and I think you have a lot of excellent information, saved to my bookmarks (:.